JOIN US FOR FREE 4HR OVERRULED CLE NOVEMBER 5th @ LOEWS HOTEL

Call Now | AVAILABLE 24/7

Attorney Brad Scott

Episode 99: Forbidden Pizza – Building One of New Orleans’ Hottest Spots

Absolutely NO FEE Unless We Win!

David Vicknair image

Episode 99: Forbidden Pizza – Building One of New Orleans’ Hottest Spots

Apr 2026 | Overruled with Scott Vicknair

What happens when a Stanford-trained attorney walks away from the traditional path to chase the perfect slice of pizza? In this episode, David sits down with Beau Baudier, founder of Forbidden Pizza, to explore his journey from law and real estate into one of New Orleans’ hottest food spots. Beau shares how a passion project turned into a breakout success, the obsession behind crafting great pizza, and the unexpected challenges of rapid growth.

Here’s what we discuss in this episode:

🍕 Beau’s passion project turned breakout success

⚙️ The extreme detail behind “simple” pizza

🔥 How growth brings unexpected challenges

👨‍🍳 Quality control is everything

📍 Forbidden Pizza’s expansion plans + future vision

0:00 – Intro & Beau’s background

2:10 – The origin of Forbidden Pizza

2:50 – Unexpected success & local buzz

5:31 – The science behind great pizza

11:16 – Building the shop experience

12:17 – Dave Portnoy review

15:10 – Growth challenges & scaling

19:47 – What’s next for Forbidden Pizza

#neworleans #neworleanseats #pizzabusiness #neworleansresturants Forbidden Pizza: https://www.forbiddenpizza.com/

Injured? Begin the process here:

Scott Vicknair Injury Lawyers: https://www.scottvicknair.com/

Car Accident Lawyer: https://www.scottvicknair.com/new-orl…

Truck Accident Lawyer: https://www.scottvicknair.com/new-orl…

Motorcycle Accident Lawyer: https://www.scottvicknair.com/new-orl…

Probate, Succession and Estate Legal Needs? Visit Scott Law Group – Estate Counsel: https://www.louisianasuccessionattorn…

Hello everybody, welcome to the Overruled podcast, brought to you by the Scott Vicknair Law Firm. I am your host, David Vicknair, my co-host Brad Scott is not here today, but we have an exciting episode to talk to you about one of, I guess, everybody’s favorite topics, pizza. I’m excited to have Beau Baudier, the proprietor and owner of Forbidden Pizza, in the podcast studio today, to talk about his journey from Stanford, being an attorney, to opening one of the hottest pizza shops and one of my favorite pizzas in the city of New Orleans, Forbidden Pizza. Beau, thank you so much for being here today.

Thanks for having me, happy to be here.

Beau, if you don’t mind, tell everybody a little about your journey, I know you went to Stanford and you’re an attorney, so a lot of interest there on my part, at least, not knowing the full story, how you kind of went along that route to where we are today with opening Forbidden, I guess it’s been open almost about a year now, is that right?

A little over a year, we opened December 5th of 2023, so a little over a year. Yeah, our journey, pizza was something my wife and I love, we found ourselves eating pizza at least once a week, twice a week, a few years ago, five years ago or so, we just didn’t really have a pizza we loved here in New Orleans, there were some decent ones, but not exactly the pizza we wanted. So the idea was, let’s create this pizza that we love, exactly the pizza we want. I actually do more real estate development than anything, we had redeveloped a building, an apartment building, and had a ground-floor commercial space that wasn’t being used, we needed to use it. We were actually in Vegas one weekend, having some late-night pizza that wasn’t the best pizza, but it tasted the best at the time.

Tastes good after four or five drinks in Vegas.

Exactly, exactly, so we’re like, well, we need to have something like this in New Orleans. So we started the process, maybe almost five years ago, starting the design, the build-out, a lot of research went into it, and yeah, we just decided to do it. It was really a passion project, we wanted to do this mostly for us, kind of scratching our own itch, we wanted a pizza we loved and a place we could go and enjoy. And yeah, it turned into something a lot bigger than that, where other people loved it as much as we do, that’s kind of how we ended up here.

So interesting, Beau, that you said this started as a passion project and it’s kind of exploded, because maybe I’m wrong, but from my purview it’s become one of the most beloved and hottest pizzas in New Orleans. It’s interesting, because I feel like until back in law school, maybe 17 years ago, was when the guys started Pizza Delicious, and that was one of the first ones I remember bringing in a true New York-style pizza, and there have been a lot of good pizzas since then, I feel like in New Orleans you’ve got the Brewery with a good pizza, you got Sez, which has a good pizza, Mid-City Pizza brought in a New York-style pizza. But you and Il Supremo hit the scene, and both your pizza shops exploded, and Forbidden Pizza is just really freaking good. So did y’all expect the kind of reaction you’ve gotten, having this be a passion project connected to the apartment building?

Yeah, no, we really didn’t, and yeah, Pizza Delicious was definitely first, they came in and did something special, and when we started the process, the design process, the R&D that went into it, they were really the only one here, then some of the others came online during our build-out process, but no, we definitely didn’t expect this level of excitement. We were just trying to make pizza we loved, and fill a commercial space in a building we had, be able to pay the rent, we weren’t trying to become something much larger than that, and the response has been amazing, something we never really expected, but it’s been awesome, and we’re grateful for it.

I think it’s a good example of, if you have a passion for something and do it well, sometimes, not always, there’ll be a response like y’all have had. I love it whenever people ask me where to go grab pizza, I’ve done like 55 pizza reviews in New Orleans, Forbidden is always one of the places I recommend, because the quality of ingredients is fantastic, the pizza’s just really freaking good, I don’t know how else to say that, and I’m not some Italian pizza connoisseur.

Right, right.

But tell me a little about the build-out itself, the attention to detail, or maybe some challenges y’all faced in really producing a product of the quality y’all’s pizza is, that people may not understand or know about the pizza business, when you were building this all out and putting it together.

Yeah, I think pizza’s very simple, it’s dough, sauce, and cheese, but inside that simple pizza there’s so much detail that goes into it, and I was also, in addition to being a lawyer, an engineer at one point, so I’ve done a million different things in life.

Real estate, engineering, lawyer, and pizza, man, that’s a full life, and you’re still pretty young.

I was an investment banker at one point too, so it might just be that I don’t know what the hell I want to do. But I think about it more in my engineering days, there’s a lot of similarity with the level of detail and focusing on very small variables that change things quite a bit. Our dough takes 24 to 36, sometimes 48 hours to make, there are multiple pre-ferments that go into it, and I hear what you’re saying, you’re not a pizza connoisseur, I’m not a wine connoisseur, when people tell me they’re tasting notes of blackberry and chocolate in their wine, I don’t know what the hell they’re talking about, but I can taste wine and say, oh, that tastes good.

Tastes good, that’s right.

And I think that’s all the little things, the pre-ferments, the time that goes into the fermentation process with our dough, all of it comes together in what you taste, and you don’t necessarily know why it tastes good, but there’s a lot of complexity of flavors that come out, and you’re like, wow, this dough tastes really good. So yeah, the dough-making process was something we focused in on a lot, this was a learning process, we learned a lot through the whole thing. One thing we did that people get excited about, but I don’t think it made as much of a difference as it sounds, we calibrated our water to be New York water, and that actually, I think, didn’t do nearly as much as just focusing on every little detail does. So in hindsight, did we need that, maybe not, but it was one of the little details we focused on. The fermentation process is really the biggest part, we bring in multiple different flours from Italy, our dough consists of five different flours, we developed this proprietary blend, and the details, the hydration percentages, the temperature of the oven, all those little things need to work together, and some of that changes from different times of the year, when it’s hotter and more humid you have to change the dough recipe a little, change the oven temperature a little, we have to dial all those things in and make the details work together.

I think it’s interesting you say that, because when I taste y’all’s dough, it’s a similar analogy to the wine we just talked about, in my mind you don’t have to know everything about wine to taste good wine and know it when you taste it. And tasting y’all’s dough, I don’t want you to tell any secrets on the show, but tasting it I’m like, how is this dough so good, so different and unique from any other pizza dough, you go grab a slice from Il Supremo or something, y’all’s dough is different and good, in a really good way, I don’t want to get into a better-than thing, it’s just really, really good. So having you explain it like that really clicked for me, how much attention to detail y’all have paid to making the product so quality, and look at the response y’all have had from people loving it, raving about it, going to the place. One of my favorite things about the build-out y’all did, I’m curious how it came about, is this really neat bar y’all set up in the shop, where you can go have a couple drinks right next to the Virgin Hotel there, and get a slice of pizza and a drink or two. How did that come about?

Yeah, so two things on that, the first, pizza’s really personal, we made what’s our favorite pizza, so when you talk about people loving it, and loving some of the other ones too, you totally get it, our pizza might not be for everybody, but it’s the one we love. It’s a thin-crust, New York-style pizza, is what it is.

Exactly.

Yeah, and some of the other components, my wife and I have a mild allergy to garlic, actually, so we don’t use any garlic in our pizzas, we went for a pizza that shines without garlic and other strong flavors that overpower the dough, we wanted something really balanced, that has dough, a delicious sauce, but the sauce doesn’t overpower the dough, and of course great cheese and toppings. But your point about the bar, yeah, my wife and I just wanted a place we would want to go, so we built it the way we would want it, kind of cozy but also with a little style to it, and very green, we love plants, so we have a green wall, the green wall hasn’t taken off nearly as well as we hoped, things are really hard to make work, but we grow some herbs on it that we use in our cocktails, it can’t produce as much as we need for the pizza, but we do harvest some herbs from the green wall for the cocktails, gives them a little fresher flavor.

Nice. How much of y’all’s customers, Beau, would you say, are tourists versus locals, because you’re in a great location right there next to the Virgin, on Bourbon, I’m assuming you pick up some tourists who heard about y’all online and want to check the pizza out. What did Dave Portnoy rate y’all’s pizza, I think he rated it really high?

Yeah, 8.3.

Yeah, and at the time he told me I had the worst reaction he’d ever gotten on the video to an 8.3, I was like, oh, thank you, man, I really appreciate that.

I don’t know who he was.

No, I definitely knew who he was, I hadn’t followed him as carefully, I’ve followed him more carefully recently, but now I know that 8.3 really is way up there for him, you hear 8.3 and it sounds like a good number, doesn’t sound exceptional, but looking back on some of his other videos, you see it is exceptional, I think he was shocked at how much he loved the pizza. For those who don’t know who Dave Portnoy is, he owns Barstool Sports, and was the first person to start doing pizza reviews, he did the pizza review for Forbidden before he did, we were a week before.

That’s right, thank you, Miles, that’s right, when he went I was like, that son of a blank, I beat you, Dave Portnoy.

And obviously getting an 8.3 from him on a pizza rating is a huge deal, hundreds of thousands of people saw that, and I think it’s just hilarious you were like, thanks man.

Yeah, no, thanks man, it was awesome, I’ve gotten a lot of shit for that from friends and my wife and everything, but at the same time, I wouldn’t necessarily take it back, we were going to make the pizza we loved no matter what, and yeah, I appreciate him coming through there for sure.

Did you even know he was coming, did you get a heads-up, or was it a total surprise?

No, no, we didn’t know, he put an order in under, I think, the cameraman’s name.

Gotcha.

We were actually building the bar next door, in this mad rush to get it ready for Super Bowl, it was the Thursday before the Super Bowl, I was over there looking at the construction, trying to figure out where things would go and how we’d make this crazy deadline we had, and I just happened to walk back over to the other side, and he was there, I was like, oh, shit, there he is. So we didn’t make a pizza especially for him, didn’t put any extra care into it, it was just the pizza as it came out, and I was proud that we didn’t try to fake a pizza to get a rating.

To get a rating.

So it came out, and it was great, I saw it come out and thought, I hope this is a good one, and it was. So the next day after the review, line around the block, like he promised, and that persisted for probably three or four months, we’d sell out every day, and we’re still doing almost the same volume, but we got a lot better, we had to increase our staff, double our refrigeration capacity, order another oven, so, all these good problems.

All these good problems.

But it was stressful too, people were getting angry that we’re selling out, and I can’t do anything about it.

Doing the best we can.

I remember a conversation with one guy, he’s like, well, just go make some more dough, and I’m like, our dough process, we can’t just whip it up in an hour or even several hours, it takes days.

Not that simple.

So yeah.

Yeah, it’s funny because I don’t think, everybody thinks growth is great and exciting, but we’re experiencing the same thing at the law firm, growth also has growth problems, solutions of, a lot of challenges and pressures you have to solve from a growth perspective. We’re in the most competitive restaurant city in the world, probably, in New Orleans, maybe New York’s a bit more competitive, but New Orleans is pretty competitive, and you come on and have the good problem, so many customers, but a lot of challenges to solve those problems, right?

Yeah, consistency and quality control, number one, I’m sure you have the same issues here at the law firm, when volume picks up a lot you want to deliver the same quality product every time, and that took, yeah, that was difficult, especially the first few months, we’ve gotten a lot better since. Consistency in pizza in general is tough, we want every pie to be our best pie, we don’t want just one outstanding pie and everyone else subpar.

Of course.

So what would you say, Beau, if you had to say one thing that surprised you in this journey, you’ve been open since the end of 2023, so about a year and a half in, what was one of the most unexpected things that’s happened since you opened, besides Dave Portnoy showing up and giving y’all, I guess, his highest rating, was it John’s or Blake’s?

No, yeah, he gave like John’s or Di Lucca’s, anywhere in New Haven, Connecticut, he gives like 9.2, 9.3.

Gotcha, but I think he was the highest in New Orleans, gave y’all an 8.3 or 8.5, gave Il Supremo an 8.1, he didn’t expect to have your pizza in New Orleans for sure, watching the review, but besides that, was there one big surprise in this pizza shop journey over the last year and a half?

I think I’ve sort of touched on it, that pizza is kind of simple but there’s such a deep rabbit hole once you start going down the different styles of pizza, different ways to make the dough, all the details, that was surprising to me, how detailed and technical it can get, even mathematical and scientific, with dough fermentation and hydration percentages, that process. That was surprising. You’re probably asking more on the business side, what was surprising there, but.

Anything.

Yeah, that was probably the biggest surprise, I’d also say it’s sometimes surprising how personal pizza is, people can get very passionate about their pizza, and that’s great, and sometimes not so great, so that’s been a little surprising. Pizza’s also interesting, I think, Beau, some pizzas you have in the shop, I’m not going to say who I’m talking about, it’s not your place, I’ll talk about your pizza in a second in a good way, it’s like some places I love their pizza in New Orleans, it’s good there but it doesn’t travel well, for whatever reason I can’t figure that out, but y’all’s pizza is good in the shop and really good traveling too. So it’s funny you say that, I do find pizza is so uniquely personal, everybody’s got a different perspective on pizza.

Definitely, definitely. But tell us what we can look forward to in the future with Forbidden, anything coming down the pike, and a little about y’all’s business hours, when you’re open, how people order, hard to miss y’all, you’re kind of everywhere online right next to the Virgin Hotel, but what can we expect from y’all in the future?

We’ve spent the last year really dialing in on quality control and consistency, and I think we’ve gotten that to a good place right now, we’ve been doing a little playing around with square pies, grandma slices, trying some new things out, so we might roll out some different ideas on that if we find something we really love. In addition, you asked about hours, we’re only open five days a week, we’re closed on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, so maybe we open another day, probably not during the summer, but if we were to do it, probably sometime in the fall or spring, the busier times, so looking into that. And everyone asks about expansion, are we going to open another one, I think the answer is not in New Orleans, this is going to be our flagship New Orleans location, and if we do open another one we were considering Baton Rouge, maybe the North Shore, and we’ll see, we’ll see if we find a place that really works for us.

Well, congratulations on the growth, I’m surprised the future plans were only potentially another location like Baton Rouge or somewhere near New Orleans, because you’ve done Stanford, lawyer, engineer, pizza, I was thinking you’d tell me you were going to be on the next Artemis rocket.

That’s giving me too much credit here, I’m just thinking about adding another pizza shop to the mix, too much credit, no, I’m actually trying to narrow in and focus a little more.

Well, amazing, thank you so much for being here, Beau, and to our listeners, I’m really glad y’all listened in, please, please, please, if you’re getting pizza in New Orleans, check out Forbidden Pizza, I say that unqualifiedly, you will not regret it, it’s one of the best pizzas in New Orleans, one of my favorites, I just had it Saturday night after Hogs, Beau, my neighbor went, and we had a big group coming back from Hogs for the Cause, dinner and Forbidden Pizza at the condo, he grabbed like 10 pizzas to go because there was a big group, some friends from out of town in Oregon, and I had six or seven friends in town, so about 14 of us, and the pizzas are huge, you can feed a lot of people.

They are, 20-inch pies, they are huge, and they travel well.

So please check out Forbidden Pizza, you can check them out online, they’re open all days of the week except Tuesday, Wednesday, and thank you so much for being here, Beau, thanks for adding such a cool new spot to downtown, I wish you, your wife, and your family continued success on the shop, because I love it, we all love it, we’re really excited to have such a good person and family with a quality product in the community.

Really appreciate that, David, thank you, it’s been awesome being here, I appreciate you having me on.

You got it, and thanks all of you, thanks so much for listening, it’s been a great discussion on one of my favorite pizzas in New Orleans, Forbidden Pizza, check them out online, and thanks for following along, we’ll see you next time on the Overruled podcast, brought to you by the Scott Vicknair Law Firm, see you next time.

Information is for illustrative purposes only and does not constitute tax, investment, or legal advice. Always consult with a qualified investment, legal, or tax professional before taking any action.

SV-LOGO

Let's Get Started on Your Case

NO FEES Unless We Win!

By providing a telephone number and submitting this form, you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. You can reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging. See our Privacy Policy for more details.

Message and Data Rates may apply. You can STOP messaging by sending STOP and get more help by sending HELP.

Want to know what your case is worth?

RECOGNIZED FOR EXCELLENCE

OUR BLOG

Insights and Updates from Our Legal Team